Car insurance can be one of the biggest yearly costs for drivers in the U.S. Thankfully, it doesn’t have to break the bank. Whether you’re a seasoned driver or just got your license, finding the right policy at the lowest price requires understanding how insurers set rates and who offers the best deals. In 2025, as prices continue to rise, shopping smart is more important than ever.
This guide breaks down the cheapest car insurance options available in 2025, based on driver profile, coverage type, and insurer performance.
Top Low-Cost Insurance Providers of 2025
Budget-Friendly Full Coverage
For drivers who want full protection—including liability, collision, and comprehensive coverage—Travelers has emerged as the top pick for affordability. On average, its full coverage policies cost about $1,776 per year, which comes out to roughly $148 per month.
Lowest Cost for Basic Coverage
If you’re just looking for the minimum state-required liability insurance, Mercury Insurance offers some of the best rates, averaging about $1,239 annually (around $103 a month).
Cheapest Providers Based on Specific Profiles
Based on Research from NerdWallet (2025):
-
Full Coverage: Travelers – approx. $1,776/year
-
Minimum Liability Only: GEICO – approx. $492/year
-
Drivers Aged 20: GEICO – around $4,105/year
-
Middle-Aged Drivers (40): Travelers – about $1,691/year
-
Seniors (70+): Travelers – roughly $1,660/year
-
Drivers with Accidents: Travelers – $2,418/year (liability only)
Forbes Advisor Analysis:
-
Clean Driving Records: Nationwide – $121/month
-
After a Speeding Ticket: Nationwide – $161/month
-
Following an Accident: Nationwide – $211/month
-
After a DUI: Progressive – $207/month
-
Poor Credit Scores: Nationwide – $173/month
-
Senior Citizens: Nationwide – $125/month
-
Young Drivers (Teen to Early 20s): Erie – $238/month
-
Teens on Parents’ Policy: Nationwide – $234/month
U.S. News Rankings:
-
National Average in 2025: $2,068/year (up from ~$1,459 in 2024)
-
Best for Good Drivers: Erie – around $1,532/year
-
Best for Military Families: USAA consistently provides the lowest prices and best service for those who qualify.
CNBC Select 2025 Overview:
-
Military/Family Members: USAA leads with affordable full coverage around $2,068/year and liability-only options as low as $597/year.
-
Extra savings available for safe driving, low mileage, and bundling policies.
Why Insurance Rates Differ (And How to Reduce Yours)
Key Factors That Affect Your Premium:
-
Coverage Level – Liability-only costs significantly less than full coverage.
-
Driving Record – Clean records save money; violations or accidents raise costs.
-
Location – State and ZIP code affect your rates due to local risk factors.
-
Credit Score – Poor credit can raise rates in many states.
-
Age and Experience – Teen drivers pay more; rates typically decrease with age (until senior years).
-
Vehicle Type – Some models are cheaper to insure due to safety ratings, repair costs, or theft risk.
-
Market Conditions – Inflation, labor costs, and repair expenses have led to a national increase in insurance premiums in 2025.
Smart Ways to Cut Your Insurance Costs:
-
Shop Around Annually – Even if you like your current insurer, compare new quotes every year.
-
Raise Your Deductible – Choosing a higher deductible can lower your premium (as long as you can afford to pay it if needed).
-
Take a Defensive Driving Course – These programs often come with discounts.
-
Bundle Insurance Policies – Combine auto and home/renters coverage for multi-policy savings.
-
Enroll in Telematics Programs – Apps like Nationwide’s SmartRide and USAA’s SafePilot reward you for safe driving.
-
Drive Less – Low-mileage drivers may qualify for additional discounts.
-
Drive an Insurance-Friendly Car – Vehicles like the Honda CR-V, Subaru Outback, and Mazda CX-5 are cheaper to insure due to their safety and reliability.
Quick Comparison Table – Cheapest Insurers for Every Situation
| Driver Situation | Best Insurer | Estimated Annual Cost |
|---|---|---|
| Minimum Coverage | Mercury | ~$1,239 |
| Full Coverage | Travelers | ~$1,776 |
| Minimum Liability (Lowest) | GEICO | ~$492 |
| Young Adult (Age 20) | GEICO | ~$4,105 |
| Driver Age 40 | Travelers | ~$1,691 |
| Senior Driver (Age 70) | Travelers | ~$1,660 |
| Post-Accident Driver | Travelers | ~$2,418 |
| Clean Record Driver | Nationwide | ~$1,452 |
| Speeding Ticket | Nationwide | ~$1,932 |
| After Major Accident | Nationwide | ~$2,532 |
| DUI Record | Progressive | ~$2,484 |
| Poor Credit | Nationwide | ~$2,076 |
| Teen on Parent’s Policy | Nationwide | ~$2,808 |
| Active Military or Veterans | USAA | ~$2,068 full / ~$597 liability |
| Good Driving Habits (U.S. News) | Erie | ~$1,532 |
Current Insurance Trends in 2025
In 2025, insurance rates are continuing to rise due to multiple market forces:
-
Tariffs on vehicle parts are raising repair costs.
-
Climate events, such as floods and hailstorms, are increasing claims.
-
Labor shortages and rising wages in the auto repair industry are also contributing.
Some states, including California and Arkansas, are already reporting average rate hikes between 7%–9%. As a result, comparing quotes and seeking out discounts is more critical than ever.
Vehicles That Are Cheaper to Insure
Choosing the right vehicle can significantly lower your premiums. According to recent data, the following vehicles are among the least expensive to insure:
-
Honda CR-V
-
Mazda CX-5
-
Subaru Outback
-
Hyundai Kona
-
Kia Niro
On average, drivers of these vehicles save up to $1,000 per year compared to the national average for full coverage.
Tips for Getting the Lowest Rate in 2025
-
Only pay for the coverage you need – If your car is older or paid off, liability-only might be sufficient.
-
Always compare quotes – Use online tools or speak with an agent to see which companies offer you the best price.
-
Leverage all available discounts – Safe driver? Student? Good credit? Ask about everything.
-
Bundle where you can – Combining policies like auto + renters/home can save money.
-
Avoid unnecessary claims – Minor repairs out-of-pocket can help you maintain a clean record.
-
Update your insurer annually – If your driving profile changes, so should your rate.
Final Thoughts
Finding the cheapest car insurance in the U.S. for 2025 means understanding what affects your rate and which companies offer the best deals for your situation.
-
Best overall full coverage: Travelers
-
Cheapest minimum coverage: GEICO and Mercury
-
Best for young and teen drivers: GEICO and Erie
-
Top choice for military families: USAA
-
Best post-accident and DUI pricing: Nationwide and Progressive
Ultimately, your best rate will come from knowing your coverage needs, regularly comparing quotes, and applying smart cost-cutting strategies.